The Automotive Advisor Team

Auto Market Update: 5-23-2025: Big Beautiful Bill

Economic Source

 Current State of Tariffs:

  • Price Increases: The average price of new vehicles has risen by approximately 13.5%. Imported models have seen price hikes of up to 31%. The Budget Lab at Yale
  • Consumer Behavior: In response to higher prices, consumers delay purchases or opt for used vehicles, leading to a slowdown in new car sales. The Budget Lab at Yale

Manufacturing and Supply Chain Disruptions

  • Production Costs: Manufacturers face increased costs due to tariffs on imported parts and materials, leading to a 10-20% rise in production expenses in key sectors.
  • Supply Chain Challenges: Just-in-time supply chains are disrupted, causing production slowdowns and delays in vehicle deliveries. Financial Times

Industry Response and Outlook

  • Automaker Strategies: Companies like Ford and Stellantis are offering promotions, such as employee pricing, to mitigate the impact on consumers. NPR
  • Market Forecast: Analysts anticipate a decline in U.S. vehicle sales, with projections dropping from 15.1 million units in 2025 to 14 million in 2026, before a potential recovery in 2027. BCG Global

The Big Beautiful Bill:

Legislation now moves to the Senate, where further debates and amendments are anticipated to add growth to the economy, but in the short term, may raise inflation.

  • Extends the 2017 Tax Cuts permanently for individuals and businesses.
  • Eliminates taxes on tips and overtime pay.
  • Raises standard deduction by $1,000 (individuals) and $2,000 (joint filers).
  • Increases Child Tax Credit to $2,500 through 2028.
  • Expands SALT deduction cap to $40,000 for incomes under $500,000.
  • Boosts small business deduction to 23%.
  • Introduces MAGA Savings Accounts for children born 2024–2028.
  • Raises estate tax exemption to $15 million.

 

Manheim Retail & Wholesales Market Source

Depreciation increased slightly as the 3 YO index moved down 0.4% to 103.8%. Lane efficiency for 3-year-old units was down 0.3% to 58.5%.

  • The 3-year-old index declined 0.4% to 103.8%.
  • All age groups were down for the second time this year (Week 18 was the other).
  • MMR retention went down 0.21% to 98.96%.
  • Lane efficiency for 3-year-old units went down 0.3% to 58.5%.
  • Retail to wholesale spreads increased as wholesale prices were slightly down while retail prices remained mostly flat. The 6-week lag spreads were down for luxury and non-luxury.
  • The spread from the retail price in red compared to the wholesale price in blue shows that the softening in buy price is creating margin opportunities.

 

  • The 3-year-old MMR Index is softening but still over 100%, suggesting vehicles are still hard to find and costly.

  • Lane efficiency measures auction activity and below we show dealer activity in the lanes is softening as well.

 

  • Year to Date, we are still up in inventory value with every vehicle age, but week to week we are seeing declining values.

  • The Depreciation index below shows, by age range, that inventory on dealers’ lots is depreciating and an assessment on age is needed.

 

  • Older inventory is seeing the softening in values as well over the last couple of weeks.

 

Black Book: Source

As we reach the midpoint of May, the wholesale market is beginning to show signs of decline. Last week, the overall car segment remained positive; however, several sub-segments experienced a downturn. Meanwhile, the overall truck segment registered its first decline in 10 weeks, although five sub-segments displayed positive movement. This marks a notable shift in market trends, with both car and truck segments demonstrating mixed performance.

The auction conversion rate last week dropped to its lowest point since the third week of February. Additionally, total auction inventory numbers were comparable to levels last seen in January, highlighting a significant shift in market activity and demand dynamics.

 

  • The average daily new car inventory is falling, creating a significant impact on supply vs demand.

 

Summary: Source

  • Market Outlook Drops Sharply: After two quarters of improvement, the market outlook index fell from 58 to 45, indicating that more dealers expect weak conditions in the next three months. Independent dealers saw the steepest decline, dropping 15 points to 42, while franchised dealers also lowered expectations, falling to 56 from 61 in Q1.
  • Customer Traffic Surges: The customer traffic index rose to 37, up from 33 in Q1 and higher than year-ago levels. Franchised dealers reported a 10-point jump in in-person visits – the largest increase since the metric was introduced in Q3 2022 – reflecting strong consumer engagement amid new tariff policies.
  • Profitability Improves: The profit index climbed to 39, the highest in over a year. Franchised dealers led the gains, rising from 41 to 52, with more dealers now viewing their profits as strong rather than weak. Independent dealers also saw modest improvement, up three points to 35.
  • Inventory Tightens: Strong vehicle sales in March and April led to tighter inventory levels. The new-vehicle inventory index dropped to 50, the lowest since late 2022, while used-vehicle inventory fell to 41. Dealers also reported reduced pressure to lower prices as inventory declined, with the price pressure index falling from 63 to 57.
John Ellis CEO & Founder of The Automotive Advisor Team, LLC

Author: John Ellis

Founder & CEO Agile Auto, The Automotive Advisor Team

LinkedIn page